- Home
- Q&A
-
Which private-market data points are most useful when comparing equity crowdfunding offerings?
The first thing that I see investors get wrong all the time when evaluating equity crowdfunding investments is that they automatically assume that a fantastic company will make a great investment.
A great company and a great investment can be two completely different things.
As Warren Buffett wrote:
... moreThe first thing that I see investors get wrong all the time when evaluating equity crowdfunding investments is that they automatically assume that a fantastic company will make a great investment.
A great company and a great investment can be two completely different things.
As Warren Buffett wrote:
“Of course, a business with terrific economics can be a bad investment if it is bought at too high a price.” — 2016 shareholder letter
With that foundation in mind:
1. Start with valuation and investment terms. What price are you paying relative to the company’s progress, potential, and risks? What would the business need to achieve to deliver an attractive return from that starting valuation? Also understand what you’re buying: the security, ownership rights, and how future fundraising could dilute your stake. Those terms help determine how business success translates into investor returns. The SEC’s crowdfunding investor bulletin highlights valuation and differences in shareholder rights as important considerations.
Remember that every great company can still be a bad investment opportunity if the valuation is too high.
Beyond that, the most useful data points depend on your objectives: financial returns, measurable impact, or some combination. I would focus on:
Evidence of traction appropriate to the stage. For an established business, examine revenue growth, customer retention, repeat purchases, and margins. For an earlier venture, look for product validation, paid pilots, technical milestones, or other evidence that reduces a specific risk. Distinguish demonstrated results from forecasts.
Market opportunity and competitive advantage. Look beyond a large headline market size. Who will actually buy, why will they choose this business, and what evidence supports its ability to reach those customers?
Cash runway and use of proceeds. How much cash is the business using, how long will the raise support operations, and what milestones should that funding achieve? Consider what happens if it raises only the minimum or growth takes longer than expected.
Measurable impact, if that is part of your goal. Look for defined outcomes, a baseline, and consistent reporting—for example, improvements in affordability or verified emissions reductions. Apply the same scrutiny to impact claims as to financial claims.
Underlying all of this is the team, especially before the business has established systems and processes. I’d look for relevant experience, complementary skills, commitment, and a compelling reason for tackling this particular problem. I’d also compare what they previously said they would accomplish with what they actually delivered. How candidly they discuss setbacks matters to me, as well as how they handle difficult investor questions in the Q&A, which can tell you a lot about a founder.
From a data-driven perspective, make sure the comparisons are meaningful: similar stages and business models, matching reporting periods, and consistent metric definitions. Revenue, bookings, and transaction volume measure different things. Check the dates and sources, and reconcile pitch-page claims with financial statements where possible.
Finally, consider how success could eventually return cash to investors. A growing business or a higher valuation on paper doesn’t, by itself, provide liquidity.
less4 -
What should a small business prepare for a crowdfunding portal’s issuer qualification process?
1. A list of 100 people's email addresses who have confirmed to you (the potential issuer) that they are as committed to the success of your venture as you are and can supply either time, talent or treasure to help you.
2. Whatever financial review your raise requires from a CPA or similar fin... more
1. A list of 100 people's email addresses who have confirmed to you (the potential issuer) that they are as committed to the success of your venture as you are and can supply either time, talent or treasure to help you.
2. Whatever financial review your raise requires from a CPA or similar financial firm. The requirements change often.
3. A report from a securities attorney on what is the most likely best issue you can make (equity, revenue share, convertible, SAFE, etc)
4. Due diligence answers. Our questions are here:
less -
When should a North Carolina business consider intrastate crowdfunding instead of Reg CF?
Rarely would I recommend NC PACES over Regulation CF, particularly now that the limited offering path in NC has sunsetted.
1 -
How can investors assess both financial potential and measurable impact in a crowdfunding offering?
Traditionally, startup investing required dozens of hours of due diligence. Many investors are tempted to cut corners. Doing so risks building a poorly performing, low-impact portfolio.
Reg CF makes investing easier and faster inherently in two key ways. The portal is required to do some screening a... more
Traditionally, startup investing required dozens of hours of due diligence. Many investors are tempted to cut corners. Doing so risks building a poorly performing, low-impact portfolio.
Reg CF makes investing easier and faster inherently in two key ways. The portal is required to do some screening and background checks that angels had to do in the past. Furthermore, much greater required disclosures accelerate due diligence.
When investing for impact, I find most early-stage and small business issuers seeking impact don't have well-refined impact measurement in place. I look for impact that could be measured.For evaluating financial returns, I look for the ability to meet contractual expectations, as I focus on small business lending more often than equity investing, giving me an opportunity to earn money in the form of interest. When investing in equity, I look for the reasonable possibility of a tenfold return.
Remember this axiom: if a deal is great in every way except valuation, it isn't a good deal. Valuation is essential!
To help with evaluating this, we have a free tool for members that guests can use for $12 per outing: https://SuperImpactScore.ai.
less1 -
What do you recommend first-time investors look for in a creator’s revenue history when evaluating an offering on GigaStar? What do you recommend first-time investors look for in a creator’s revenue history when evaluating an offering on GigaStar?
The first thing to know is that some of this homework is done before an offering reaches you, because a channel has to meet minimum thresholds before GigaStar will consider it. We also verify revenue metrics directly from YouTube through an API, and we run a background check and interview every Crea... more
- Funding Portals (FINRA)
-
After a crowdfunding raise, how can a founder figure out which investors to approach first for customer introductions? After a crowdfunding raise, how can a founder figure out which investors to approach first for customer introductions?
This is difficult because you don’t get much information from the portal. That’s why I built thru.
you can upload a simple CSV from your portal, tell us your customer profile and we find the best matches. Happy to show you! Send me an email joey@comethru.co
... more -
Is there an official summit hotel, and where should out-of-town attendees stay? Is there an official summit hotel, and where should out-of-town attendees stay?
There is no official hotel block or negotiated CfPA room rate for the 2026 CfPA Regulated Investment Crowdfunding Summit. CfPA is a nonprofit 501(c)(6) trade association managed by all-volunteer industry leadership, so we are providing the following courtesy shortlist rather than administering a hot... more
- Media, Events & Publications
- Regulations & Compliance
-
Are there sponsorship opportunities for the 2026 CfPA Crowdfunding Summit? Are there sponsorship opportunities for the 2026 CfPA Crowdfunding Summit?
Yes! The Crowdfunding Professional Association (CfPA) is offering multiple sponsorship opportunities for the 2026 Regulated Investment Crowdfunding Summit, which will be held in Washington, D.C. on October 20-21, 2026. The event includes a full day of advocacy visits on Capitol Hill and with regulat... more
- Media, Events & Publications
- Regulations & Compliance
-
What kind of company is a good candidate for crowdfunding? What kind of company is a good candidate for crowdfunding?
Thanks for the question. If you ask ten different experts, you may get ten different responses. From our perspective, a good candidate for crowdfunding is a company that passes five practical tests: first, it has a strong story that people can understand, believe, and repeat; second, it has a reacha... more
- Consultants
-
Why would an issuer need insurance for a crowdfunding raise?
Bottom line: D&O for capital raises already exists. TigerMark is right-sized coverage at the right price for crowdfunding issuers.
Anytime a company raises outside capital and offers a security, the board or investors typically require D&O insurance. This isn't new. VC-backed, PE-backed, and... more
Bottom line: D&O for capital raises already exists. TigerMark is right-sized coverage at the right price for crowdfunding issuers.
Anytime a company raises outside capital and offers a security, the board or investors typically require D&O insurance. This isn't new. VC-backed, PE-backed, and institutionally funded companies have carried D&O coverage for decades. It's table stakes for professional capital formation.
The difference with crowdfunding is who you're raising from and how you're reaching them. Standard D&O policies were written for companies raising from accredited, institutional investors through private networks. Those policies often exclude claims arising from public offerings or general solicitation, which is exactly what Reg CF, Reg A+, and Reg D 506(c) involve.
That leaves crowdfunding issuers with two bad options: buy standard private company D&O that doesn't actually cover their real exposure, or overpay for full public company D&O designed for NASDAQ-listed companies.
That's why we built TigerMark. It's purpose-built for JOBS Act capital raises and covers what standard policies don't:
Claims from unaccredited investors in Reg CF and Reg A+ offerings
General solicitation exposure in Reg D 506(c) raises (where you're publicly advertising to accredited investors)
Specific compliance coverages for securities offerings not available elsewhere
Defense costs when an investor sues (securities litigation runs $250K-$500K+ before trial)
The ability to return investor principal if they allege wrongdoing
TigerMark also covers past or future Reg D 506(b) raises for traditional D&O risks, so your full capital-raising history is protected under one policy.Beyond the coverage itself, TigerMark lets you showcase to your investors that your offering and company are safeguarded. You can display the TigerMark logo, share your policy summary, and demonstrate that you've taken the same governance steps that institutional-grade companies take.
less- Unclassified
1