Why a proposed restriction on minimum and maximum offering amounts could undermine one of Reg CF's strengths
As the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) considers reforms to Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF), an important debate is emerging over how much flexibility companies should have in structuring their offerings.
In a November 12, 2026 article published by Columbia Law School's CLS Blue Sky Blog, titled “Fix Regulation Crowdfunding Before Expanding It”, University of Colorado law professor Andrew A. Schwartz argues that companies should face tighter restrictions on the relationship between their minimum and maximum offering amounts.
His concern is understandable. His proposed solution, however, could unnecessarily constrain Reg CF without delivering a corresponding benefit to investors.
Is It Really a Target, or Is It a Minimum?
Schwartz cites a 2025 SEC staff study showing that the median target offering amount through 2024 was $25,000, while the median maximum offering amount was $800,000.
Under Reg CF's all-or-nothing structure, a company must meet its stated target before it can close its offering. Schwartz argues that setting such a low target relative to the maximum undermines investor protection because a company might complete its offering with only a fraction of the capital it had hoped to raise.
But perhaps the first step is to reconsider the terminology.
Instead of calling it a "target," why not simply call it what it is: a minimum?
In fact, the SEC itself describes the target offering amount as the minimum amount of investment commitments needed for an offering to close.
The distinction matters. A maximum offering amount reflects how much capital a company is prepared to accept. It does not necessarily represent how much capital the company must raise to pursue a viable business plan.
A company might have a credible strategy for deploying $25,000, another for $200,000, and an expanded strategy for $800,000. The existence of a larger potential raise does not automatically invalidate the smaller one.
Importantly, the median minimum and median maximum cited in the SEC study are aggregate figures. They do not, by themselves, establish that the typical company needs its maximum offering amount to execute its business plan.
Why Put a Collar on Reg CF?
Schwartz proposes limiting the ratio between the maximum and minimum amounts, suggesting a four-to-one ratio as one possibility.
Under that approach, a company seeking to raise up to $800,000 would need to establish a minimum of at least $200,000. Conversely, a company setting a minimum of $25,000 could raise no more than $100,000.
But what investor-protection benefit would justify imposing such an arbitrary collar?
Reg CF is already subject to substantial regulatory requirements, including issuer disclosures, intermediary oversight, investor limits, and restrictions on communications.
Adding a fixed mathematical relationship between the minimum and maximum offering amounts would further constrain one of Reg CF's strengths: flexibility.
Companies have different business models, capital requirements, development stages, and strategic objectives. A uniform ratio cannot account for those differences.
A $25,000 minimum may be entirely appropriate for one company and wholly inadequate for another. The appropriate amount should depend on the company's circumstances and the business plan disclosed to investors, not an arbitrary percentage of the maximum raise.
Capital Formation Isn't the Only Measure of Value for Reg CF
Another important consideration is that companies don't necessarily pursue Reg CF exclusively to raise capital.
For some issuers, the marketing, awareness, customer acquisition, and community-building benefits of a crowdfunding campaign may be equally important.
Consider a company that would otherwise spend a substantial amount of money on traditional marketing to reach potential customers, introduce a new product, build brand recognition, or establish a community around its mission.
A Reg CF campaign can potentially accomplish many of those same objectives while simultaneously raising capital and creating an opportunity for individuals to become investors in the business.
For some companies, a campaign that generates enough capital to cover its costs while also attracting customers, advocates, and a community of engaged stakeholders may represent a worthwhile outcome.
Even where net investment proceeds are relatively modest, the broader economic value of the campaign can be meaningful.
This doesn't mean every crowdfunding campaign will deliver those benefits, nor does it eliminate the need for a credible business plan. It simply recognizes that the economic rationale for conducting a Reg CF offering can extend beyond the amount of capital raised.
A mandatory minimum-to-maximum ratio would fail to account for this broader value proposition.
Let the Crowd Decide
Schwartz correctly emphasizes that a central premise of investment crowdfunding is allowing the crowd, rather than the intermediary, to determine which companies deserve financial support.
But that principle arguably supports maintaining flexibility rather than imposing a prescribed ratio.
If an issuer clearly discloses its minimum offering amount, maximum offering amount, intended use of proceeds, and the risks associated with raising less than the maximum, investors can evaluate those circumstances for themselves.
The investor can then decide whether the company's minimum financing scenario represents a reasonable basis for making an investment.
That is a meaningful exercise of investor choice.
A fixed regulatory collar, by contrast, substitutes a mathematical rule for the judgment of both the issuer and the crowd.
Better Disclosure, Not Arbitrary Restrictions
The legitimate concern underlying Schwartz's proposal is whether a company can accomplish something meaningful with the minimum amount it raises.
That's a fair question, and one that issuers should be expected to answer.
Reg CF requires issuers to disclose their intended use of proceeds and permits them to explain how their plans would change depending on the amount raised.
Rather than introducing a new restriction, the SEC could focus on making those disclosures clearer and more useful to investors.
Companies should explain what they intend to accomplish if they raise only the minimum, what additional capital would enable them to do, and how their plans and risks change across different funding levels.
Investors should have enough information to assess whether the minimum raise supports a credible strategy.
The goal should be informed investor decision-making, not an arbitrary relationship between two numbers.
The Value of Diverse Industry Perspectives
Policy proposals like this are debated extensively by practitioners with diverse perspectives through the committees and subcommittees of the Crowdfunding Professional Association (CfPA).
These discussions can be spirited, and consensus is not always reached, but they are invariably thoughtful and informed by real-world experience. Funding portals, issuers, attorneys, investors, service providers, and other industry participants often approach the same regulatory question from very different perspectives.
I would encourage anyone interested in shaping the future of Reg CF to join the conversation. Hearing the wide range of perspectives from those working in the industry can help identify unintended consequences before well-intentioned policy proposals become regulatory requirements.
Preserving the Promise of Regulation Crowdfunding
As the SEC considers ways to make Reg CF more attractive to issuers and investors, it should be cautious about adding constraints that may limit legitimate financing strategies without demonstrably improving investor outcomes.
Regulation Crowdfunding was designed to expand access to capital and allow ordinary individuals to participate in financing businesses they believe in.
We should preserve that opportunity rather than narrowing it with additional restrictions.
Better disclosure, not arbitrary restrictions.
Register for FREE to comment or continue reading this article. Already registered? Login here.
1