- Home
- Q&A
-
Hi Brian, Thanks for helping the community by answering questions. Based on your personal experience with 200+ startup investments, how do you pick a startup with the limited data available and without understanding other competitors? I know there is no crystal clear...
Thanks for the question. Quick disclaimer: this is just my own personal preference and experience, this is not to be construed as investment advice! Each investor has their own reasons and criteria when investing, so you need to determine what that looks like for you.
When personally picking a compa... more
Thanks for the question. Quick disclaimer: this is just my own personal preference and experience, this is not to be construed as investment advice! Each investor has their own reasons and criteria when investing, so you need to determine what that looks like for you.
When personally picking a company to invest in, for me, it comes down to two primary things:
1. Does it match my investment thesis (e.g. my "why" for investing - whether it's a company I am passionate about, a market I think will be huge, a technology that I believe could change the world), and
2. Due diligence - e.g. are there any red flags? Are the deal terms fair? etc.
For point one: I recommend investors reflect on the reasons they are investing and what they want to achieve. Are you only looking to maximize financial returns? Do you care about social impact? Are you trying to support local small businesses?
For point two: personally, I follow a "5 T's" approach to due diligence. Due diligence is a topic that could fill volumes by itself, but you can read more about due diligence in two articles I wrote and videos I made:
Due Diligence Part 1 - https://crowdwise.org/crowd-investing-101/due-diligence-101-overview-for-crowdfunding-investors-part-1/
Due Diligence Part 2 - https://crowdwise.org/crowd-investing-101/due-diligence-101-part-2-the-1-reason-why-startups-fail-and-how-to-screen-deals/
There are also services out there that will aggregate and review deals to help investors scale their due diligence, such as KingsCrowd (disclaimer: I am currently VP of Product at KingsCrowd).
And ultimately, you should always go to the campaign page and read all the details, including all deal terms. Another gem of information on these pages are the investor Q&A sections. You can not only post your own questions to be answered by the founder, but you can read other insightful questions from potential investors of all backgrounds.
I always read the Q&A. You can learn a lot about the company and how they communicate and handle tough questions.
Happy investing!
less3 -
Hi Sara, you come recommended as a real expert in this field. I have a question that I'm hoping you can answer. During the Testing The Waters phase, is it possible to solicit feedback from a pool of potential investors on deal terms that would appeal to them in order to determin
Thanks!
Yes, you can solicit as to what terms people might find attractive, including valuation. I would generally include a disclaimer of some kind saying that just because something has been suggested it doesn't mean that will be reflected in the deal terms if you eventually make an offering.
&nbs... more
Thanks!
Yes, you can solicit as to what terms people might find attractive, including valuation. I would generally include a disclaimer of some kind saying that just because something has been suggested it doesn't mean that will be reflected in the deal terms if you eventually make an offering.
Sara
less2 -
Crowd funding is awesome for retail investors! One challenge I would see with crowdfunding are following. How do we mitigate these? - Start up founders are more and more getting greedy with valuations with no product/proof of concept in hand. A lot of tooling is needed to provid
Both valid comments, there are a few quick answers to make the severity of these problems perhaps less worrisome:
1) the average investment in a successful crowdfunding campaign is only $96. So, the real risk vis a vis the founder's self-proclaimed valuation is not only mitigated by this avera... more
Both valid comments, there are a few quick answers to make the severity of these problems perhaps less worrisome:
1) the average investment in a successful crowdfunding campaign is only $96. So, the real risk vis a vis the founder's self-proclaimed valuation is not only mitigated by this average, but there are also caps on how much a retail investor can invest annually in crowdfunding. For instance, anyone earning under $107,000 annually, can only commit $2200 or so. 5% of their annual income. I'd say there are far more dangerous "investments" people make with far more predictably bad outcomes (hamburgers?).
2) as to how to know if other, potentially better, candidates for your money are making similar solutions available to investors, that's always hard to say, but I'd say you might reconcile "Caveat Emptor" dictates responsibility in both of these questions: "the principle that the buyer alone is responsible for checking the quality and suitability of goods before a purchase is made."
So, do your homework. I mean, you' wouldn't buy a house sight-unseen without looking over the neighborhood, checking out the schools, etc.
Great questions. Keep em comin'
less -
Hi, I have been investing through seedinvest, wefunder and republic etc. i can check my portfolio in their websites. - Is there any way i can request physical copies to prove the ownership? Or in other words, who is the guarantor for shares as i heard there can be an escro
Hi - You should contact the applicable funding portal with your request. You can find their contact information on the site and in their terms of service.
0 -
What are the type of securities used on the top Reg CF platforms?
Here is a breakdown from KingsCrowd for the most popular security types for Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF) in 2022 so far:
As the figures show, the most popular security types in Reg CF in 2022 are:
1. SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) - $128.8M, 41%
2. Equity (Common) - $114.7M, 36%
3. E... more
Here is a breakdown from KingsCrowd for the most popular security types for Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF) in 2022 so far:
As the figures show, the most popular security types in Reg CF in 2022 are:
1. SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) - $128.8M, 41%
2. Equity (Common) - $114.7M, 36%
3. Equity (Preferred) - $55.4M, 17%
4. Convertible Note - $17.9M, 6%
One can see that the type of security offered also various by platform, as platforms tend to prefer (or avoid) certain financial instruments.
For example, SAFEs are the most popular on Republic and Wefunder, while StartEngine is primarily Equity (Common).
For more details on security types in equity crowdfunding deals and their differences, check out the article I wrote here:
https://crowdwise.org/crowd-investing-101/part-4-deal-types-equity-crowdfunding/
less -
Are there any helpful crowdfunding events coming soon?
Glad to learn of your interest in regulated investment crowdfunding (#RIC).
Yes, there are a few upcoming events in the space ...
SuperCrowd22 will include a Who's Who in regulated crowdfunding and will examine the intersection of crowdfunding and impact investing. It is a web-based event bein... more
Glad to learn of your interest in regulated investment crowdfunding (#RIC).
Yes, there are a few upcoming events in the space ...
SuperCrowd22 will include a Who's Who in regulated crowdfunding and will examine the intersection of crowdfunding and impact investing. It is a web-based event being co-hosted by the Crowdfunding Professional Association (CfPA), Brainsy, and many other impactful organizations September 15-16 (registration link is here: https://www.supercrowd22.com/httpssupercrowd22comtextandpercent20otherpercent20experts-register-joinpercent20thepercent20supercrowd ) For more info, follow up with Devin Thorpe
Equity Crowdfunding Week is another event that takes place a week later in person in LA (September 21-23) or online - https://www.startupstarter.co/ecw For more info, follow up with Etan Butler
Silicon Prairie Crowdfunding often hosts webinars on Wednesdays on various topics related to crowdfunding (for beginners to experienced hands) and you can see a list of their events at: https://www.meetup.com/silicon-prairie-fundraising For more info, follow up with David Duccini
Stay tuned on the CfPA ECO as CfPA often hosts events or promotes the events of members organizations.
less -
Form C-TR question on timing of filing.
Answering a question with a question: how would engaging a transfer agent reduce the number of holders of record?
-
How would you define impact crowdfunding?
Great question!
Impact crowdfunding is what is happening at the intersection of investment crowdfunding and impact investing.
As you know, investment crowdfunding was authorized by the bipartisan 2012 JOBS Act. It was initially implemented in 2016 with a $1 million cap, which was increased to $5 mil... more
Great question!
Impact crowdfunding is what is happening at the intersection of investment crowdfunding and impact investing.
As you know, investment crowdfunding was authorized by the bipartisan 2012 JOBS Act. It was initially implemented in 2016 with a $1 million cap, which was increased to $5 million last year. The space is mushrooming quickly.
Impact investing is less well known to our community but is a bigger global phenomenon dominated by wealthy families and institutions. They invest money for a financial return and a social mission. For instance, a venture capitalist backing Tesla in the early days would describe herself as an impact investor. She got a huge financial return and radically accelerated a transition to electric vehicles.
Investment crowdfunding allows for impact investing in the crowdfunding space. I call that impact crowdfunding.
SuperCrowd22 is a conference we're holding on September 15-16, 2022, to help everyone learn more about the space, both from an investor standpoint and from a social entrepreneur standpoint.
Don't miss it!
http://SuperCrowd22.com
less -
Good day, As a group of crowdfunding expertsI am hopeful you can steer me in the right direction. We are looking to crowdfund an Arizona permitted approved gold mining opportunity for $1,000,000, which is our immediate concern, and the next tranche would be for about...
Jordan, this is a great question. Thanks for coming to the CfPA Ecosystem for insights.
Of course, there is no industry or sector that can be thought of as traditionally raising money via crowdfunding. The industry is too new, implemented just six years ago and really gaining scale only in the past ... more
Jordan, this is a great question. Thanks for coming to the CfPA Ecosystem for insights.
Of course, there is no industry or sector that can be thought of as traditionally raising money via crowdfunding. The industry is too new, implemented just six years ago and really gaining scale only in the past two years. We're all learning.
There is no reason you can't crowdfund for a gold mining operation. Obviously, this is a great time to be investing in gold.
FINRA-registered portals are required to do some screening to prevent fraudsters from attempting to raise money on their platforms. Portals are allowed to do some additional screening to curate a theme. They are not allowed to imply that they have done thorough underwriting of an offering. Broker-Dealers, like Start Engine, that operate portals are allowed to do more and charge more than the other portals, including offering more help raising money.
Some platforms focus on serving small business, real estate, tech or other niches. While I haven't spotted a portal focused on extractive industries, one may exist. However, you can test out the large players (Wefunder, Republic and StartEngine) where you are most likely to find admission.
You want to remember that there is no magic crowd; the money you raise will come from your networks primarily.
Good luck!
less2 -
What are key differences between a Crowdfunding SAFE and a "Traditional" SAFE?
For the complete answer we drafted to answer this, please read our complete blog post on Traditional SAFE vs. Crowdfunding SAFE.
A brief summary of some of the key differences include:
1. Crowdfunding SAFEs may have optional conversions: in some crowdfunding SAFEs (such as Republic’s Crowd Safe), sh... more
For the complete answer we drafted to answer this, please read our complete blog post on Traditional SAFE vs. Crowdfunding SAFE.
A brief summary of some of the key differences include:
1. Crowdfunding SAFEs may have optional conversions: in some crowdfunding SAFEs (such as Republic’s Crowd Safe), shares convert at the next equity financing round at the discretion of the issuer (i.e the startup). While most traditional SAFEs are forced to convert at the next qualified financing round, many crowdfunding SAFEs give the company the option to either convert to equity or defer conversion until a later time.
While this may sound like a bad thing for investors at first, there are situations when investors can actually benefit from this delayed conversion (e.g. they may actually experience less dilution due to follow-on raises than other equity investors).
2. Crowdfunding SAFEs may convert to Shadow Series shares: in the Republic Crowd Safe, the SAFE may convert to shadow shares, which means the same class of shares (e.g. Common vs. Preferred) as other investors, but with limited voting and information rights.
3. Crowdfunding SAFEs Investing via an SPV: When you invest in a SAFE on Wefunder, you’ll often be investing in a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV). While this is typical for angel investors on sites like AngelList, this means you’ll actually be investing in the SPV (e.g. “Company X, a Series of Wefunder SPV LLC”), and not be directly investing in the company itself.Investing in an SPV may have potential tax implications (because the SPV is an LLC). Furthermore, investing in an SPV may have implications in terms of the potential future liquidity of that investment due to complications when listing SPV shares on a secondary market.
4. Many Crowdfunding SAFEs are still Pre-Money: while the standard Y-Combinator SAFE was changed to convert based upon post-money valuation in 2018, many of the SAFEs used on crowdfunding sites today are still using pre-money valuation for the conversion price.
5. Some Crowdfunding SAFEs may have repurchase rights: something that most VCs and angel SAFEs would never have is a “repurchase rights” or “redemptive clause”. These terms allow the company to buyback SAFE investors at the company’s discretion, which typically happens if a later-stage VC wants to “clean up” the cap table (i.e. get more control and ownership for themselves) or when the company is doing well and wants to buy out early investors. It's my personal opinion that investors should typically avoid SAFEs with these terms. These terms put the company’s best interests at odds with that of the investors’.
The good news is that I personally have not seen any SAFEs recently with these repurchase terms (although I have seen some Common Stock offerings on some platforms with repurchase rights, so be careful!). It seems that crowdfunding portals have realized that these repurchase rights often end poorly for investors and are used by issuers who might not have their crowdfunding investors’ best interests at heart.
less4
Powered by Brainsy, Inc. (Patented and Patents Pending)